Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Beyond the Price Tag: What Really Matters When Comparing Insurance Policies

Article overview: The cheapest insurance policy isn’t always the best value. Coverage limits determine your maximum payout, deductibles affect what you pay out-of-pocket before coverage kicks in, and exclusions reveal what’s not covered at all. Evaluating these three factors together gives a clearer picture of true value than price alone.

 

A low premium can feel like a win until the moment you actually need to file a claim. That’s when policyholders often discover the fine print they skimmed past during the shopping process. A coverage limit too low to replace a damaged home, a deductible that eats into savings, or an exclusion that leaves a major risk unprotected – these gaps can turn an affordable policy into an expensive mistake.

Comparing insurance policies effectively means looking past the monthly premium and examining how a policy actually performs when it’s put to the test. This guide breaks down the three factors that matter most: coverage limits, deductibles, and exclusions. Understanding each one helps buyers make informed decisions and avoid unpleasant surprises down the road.

  1. What are coverage limits, and why do they matter?

A coverage limit is the maximum amount an insurance company will pay out for a covered claim. This cap can apply to the policy as a whole or to specific categories within it, such as liability, personal property, or medical expenses.

Choosing a policy with inadequate limits is one of the most common – and costly – mistakes buyers make. If a homeowner’s policy caps dwelling coverage at $200,000 but rebuilding the home would actually cost $300,000, the policyholder is left to cover the $100,000 gap out of pocket.

Choose higher coverage limits if the cost of replacing your assets or covering potential liabilities exceeds the policy’s default cap. This is especially relevant for homeowners in high-cost construction markets, drivers with significant assets to protect, or business owners carrying substantial liability risk.

To evaluate whether coverage limits are sufficient, buyers should:

  • Calculate the actual replacement cost of their home, vehicle, or business assets – not just the purchase price or current market value.
  • Review liability limits against personal net worth, since a lawsuit exceeding policy limits can put personal assets at risk.
  • Ask providers about umbrella policies, which extend liability coverage beyond a standard policy’s limits.
  1. How do deductibles affect the overall cost of a policy?

A deductible is the amount a policyholder pays out-of-pocket before insurance coverage begins. Generally, policies with higher deductibles come with lower premiums, while lower deductibles mean higher premiums. This trade-off is central to comparing insurance options.

The right deductible depends on financial circumstances and risk tolerance. A $2,000 deductible might lower monthly costs significantly, but it only makes sense if the policyholder has $2,000 readily available in the event of a claim.

Choose a lower deductible if predictable monthly costs matter more than minimizing premiums, particularly for those without a robust emergency fund. Conversely, financially stable buyers who rarely file claims may save more over time with a higher deductible and lower premium.

A few considerations when evaluating deductibles:

  • Some policies, particularly homeowners insurance in disaster-prone areas, carry separate deductibles for specific events like hurricanes or earthquakes—often calculated as a percentage of the dwelling coverage rather than a flat dollar amount.
  • Health insurance plans often include both individual and family deductibles, which can significantly affect out-of-pocket costs for larger households.
  • A lower premium paired with a high deductible isn’t automatically a better deal. It’s worth running the numbers on what a realistic claim scenario would cost in total.
  1. What exclusions should buyers watch for in a policy?

Exclusions are specific situations, events, or types of damage that a policy does not cover. Every insurance policy has them, and they’re often buried in sections buyers are tempted to skip.

Overlooking exclusions can be financially devastating. Standard homeowners insurance, for example, typically excludes flood damage – a coverage gap that becomes painfully clear only after water has already ruined a home. Similarly, many auto policies exclude coverage for rideshare driving unless a specific endorsement is added.

As another example, a standard homeowner’s policy from most major insurers excludes flood and earthquake damage by default, requiring separate policies like those offered through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) for full protection.

Common exclusions worth investigating include:

  • Natural disasters: Floods, earthquakes, and sometimes windstorms are frequently excluded from standard property policies.
  • Business use of personal property: Running a business from home or using a personal vehicle for rideshare driving often isn’t covered under standard policies.
  • Pre-existing conditions: Many health and life insurance policies include waiting periods or exclusions related to conditions diagnosed before the policy’s start date.
  • Wear and tear: Most policies exclude gradual damage from aging or lack of maintenance, covering only sudden, accidental events.

Reading the exclusions section isn’t optional due diligence – it’s a critical step in understanding what a policy truly protects against.

  1. How should these factors be weighed together?

Coverage limits, deductibles, and exclusions don’t exist in isolation. A policy with generous coverage limits but a long list of exclusions might offer less real-world protection than a more modest policy with fewer gaps. Likewise, a low deductible paired with low coverage limits could mean smaller out-of-pocket costs per claim, but inadequate protection for a major loss.

The most effective way to compare policies is to build a simple side-by-side table listing each policy’s premium, coverage limits by category, deductible amounts, and key exclusions. This format makes it far easier to spot the trade-offs than scanning multiple dense policy documents separately.

It’s also worth asking insurance providers direct questions: What happens if a claim exceeds the coverage limit? Are there ways to lower the deductible without a significant premium increase? What riders or endorsements are available to close common exclusion gaps?

Making an informed choice

Price will always be a factor in choosing an insurance policy, but it shouldn’t be the deciding one. Coverage limits determine how much protection is actually available, deductibles shape the real cost of filing a claim, and exclusions define the boundaries of what’s covered in the first place.

Buyers who take the time to compare these details – rather than defaulting to the lowest premium – put themselves in a far stronger position when they actually need to rely on their coverage. Before signing on with any provider, request a full policy document, not just a summary, and don’t hesitate to ask questions about anything that seems unclear.

Contact Brandon Patterson from our team at brandon@ownbyinsurance.com to get your policy comparison questions answered.

How Claims Impact Your Insurance Premiums

Your insurance premium is based on many factors, from the type of coverage you choose to your overall risk profile. But one aspect that often surprises policyholders is the impact of claims on their premiums. Whether you’ve recently filed a claim or you’re thinking about it, it’s important to understand how claims can influence the cost of your coverage.

Loss History: A Snapshot of Your Risk

Your loss history, or claims history, is a critical factor insurers use to determine your premium. This is essentially a record of all the claims you’ve filed in the past. Insurers view this as a representation of your risk level – policyholders who have filed multiple claims are generally seen as more likely to file additional claims in the future.

Each insurer has its own thresholds for how claims history impacts your premiums, but generally, past claims can lead to higher premiums.

Why Does Your Loss History Matter Impact Your Insurance Premiums?

Your loss history paints a picture for your insurer. For example:

  • If you’ve experienced multiple incidents, it could indicate a higher likelihood of future claims.
  • A long history of claims, even if they’re for relatively small amounts, can label you as a higher-risk policyholder.

While you can’t change your past claims, being aware of how your loss history is assessed can influence your approach to future claims.

Claim Frequency and Size Matter

Number of Claims

In insurance, the old saying “the fewer, the better” rings true. Filing multiple claims within a short time – even for small amounts – can signal a higher risk level to your insurer. Insurers often see frequent claims as an indicator of risk-prone behavior, even if the claims themselves are low-cost.

To manage your premium effectively:

  • Avoid filing claims for minor damages that fall close to or just above your deductible.
  • Consider whether the cost of repairing or replacing an item out-of-pocket is more affordable in the long run.

Claim Size

The size of the claim matters just as much as the number. Large claims require significant payouts from the insurer. When an insurer has to pay a big settlement for a loss, the chances are your premium will move upward to reflect the cost.

For instance, a single high-value claim – such as a major accident or property damage – might have a bigger impact on premiums than several smaller claims.

The Impact of Your Deductible Choice

Your insurance deductible – the amount you agree to pay out-of-pocket before your insurance kicks in – also plays a major role in claims and premiums. Filing claims for damages that barely exceed your deductible can lead to higher premiums in the future, meaning you’re left paying more overall.

The Value of a Claims-Free Credit

Insurance providers often reward policyholders who don’t file any claims over a certain period. This is commonly known as a claims-free discount or credit. Maintaining a claims-free record demonstrates a lower risk level, which insurers may reward with a reduced premium or special discounts.

Filing a claim could result in the loss of this credit, which can significantly increase your premiums in the long term. Depending on your provider, the impact of losing a claims-free credit can sometimes outweigh the benefit of filing a minor claim.

“Then Why Do I Even Have Insurance?”

All this doesn’t mean you should avoid filing claims entirely. Insurance exists to protect you in situations where the losses are too great to bear out-of-pocket. However, carefully evaluating the situation and considering the long-term implications can help you balance coverage with premium stability.

Smart Tips to Manage Insurance Claims and Premiums:

  1. Review Your Policy Carefully
    Understand your deductible amount, what types of incidents are covered, and how claims may impact things like claims-free discounts.
  2. Weigh Filing a Claim Against Out-of-Pocket Costs
    If the repair or replacement cost is close to your deductible, it may save you money long-term to pay out-of-pocket rather than file a claim.
  3. Keep Your Loss History in Mind
    Evaluate how additional claims could impact your overall risk profile and premiums.
  4. Focus on Preventative Measures
    Take steps to avoid future incidents, such as securing your home, maintaining your property, or installing safety features. Proactively reducing risks can help keep your premiums manageable over time.
  5. Bundle Your Insurance Policies
    Many insurers offer discounts for bundling, which can offset increased premiums due to claims.
  6. Ask About Claims Forgiveness
    Some insurers offer “claims forgiveness” features, where your first claim won’t impact your premium. Consider whether this add-on is available and worth adding to your policy.

When to File

Ultimately, balancing the cost of a claim versus the long-term implications for your premium is key. By thinking strategically and being proactive, you can ensure your insurance remains both effective and affordable. If you’re unsure, discuss the deductibles and potential impacts of filing the claim with our team and we’ll help you understand your options – but we won’t make the choice for you. That’s your decision!

Why Aren’t all Insurance Policies the Same?

It’s a reasonable question to ask. If I am looking at a home insurance policy with insurance company A versus one with company B – shouldn’t they offer the same coverage? Isn’t cost the determining factor in the difference? The answer, however, is much more complicated.

Insurance companies in Tennessee file policies and rates with the Department of Insurance. These policies contain the specifics of what they’re going to offer, and the rate schedule for what they intend to charge. They are based on specific calculations for each company, and are often very different. While many use “forms” from the Insurance Service Office (ISO) that are the same, changes and even proprietary forms are use across the industry. So, what do you need to know about how and why they’re different? Let’s review it.

The Key Policy Differences You Should Know

1. Limits on Amounts of Coverage

One of the fundamental differences between insurance policies is the limit on the amounts of coverage they provide. Coverage limits dictate the maximum amount an insurer will pay for a covered loss. For example, a homeowners’ policy may have different limits for dwelling, personal property, and liability coverages. It’s essential to review these limits and ensure they align with your needs and financial situation. Insufficient coverage can leave you vulnerable, while excessive coverage might result in higher premiums than necessary.

2. Policy Exclusions

Policy exclusions are specific conditions or circumstances under which the insurance company will not provide coverage. These exclusions vary widely between policies and can significantly impact the protection you receive. Common exclusions include natural disasters, acts of war, and certain high-risk activities. Understanding these exclusions is critical, as they can affect your claims process and financial recovery in the event of a loss.

3. Named Perils vs. “Open” Perils Coverage

Insurance policies generally fall into two categories regarding covered perils:

  • Named Perils: This type of policy only covers losses caused by perils explicitly listed in the policy, such as fire, theft, or vandalism. If a peril is not named, it is not covered.
  • Open Perils (or All-Risk): These policies provide broader coverage, protecting against all perils unless specifically excluded in the policy. While typically more expensive, all-risk policies offer broader protection.

Choosing between named perils and all-risk coverage depends on your specific needs, risk exposure, and budget considerations.

4. Options for Endorsements

Endorsements, also known as riders or add-ons, allow policyholders to customize their insurance policies by adding specific coverages or modifying existing ones. These options enable you to tailor your policy to better fit your unique circumstances. Common endorsements include:

  • Extended Replacement Cost: Provides additional coverage for rebuilding costs that exceed the policy’s stated limits.
  • Personal Property Replacement Cost: Ensures that lost or damaged personal property is replaced at current market value rather than depreciated value.
  • Water Backup Coverage: Covers damage caused by water backing up through sewers or drains.

Reviewing available endorsements and selecting those that address your particular needs can enhance your overall protection and peace of mind.

Why Do These Policies Change Over Time?

Insurance companies continually adapt their policies to address evolving risks and limit their exposure. These changes are often based on extensive data analysis, loss history, and actuarial studies. For instance, following a surge in natural disasters, insurers may revise coverage terms, exclusions, or premium rates to reflect the increased risk. Staying informed about these adaptations is essential, as they can impact your coverage and the affordability of your policy.

Navigating the world of insurance can be complex, but understanding the key differences between policies is crucial for making informed decisions. By considering coverage limits, policy exclusions, types of coverage, and available endorsements, you can select a policy that provides the protection you need. An agent can help you understand the coverages and options available to you. Contact Brandon Patterson on our team at brandon@ownbyinsurance.com to get the support you need today!

What Does a “High Net Worth” Client Look Like in Insurance?

You may have seen the term “high net worth” somewhere and thought, “That’s not me, we’re not ‘rich’ we’re just upper middle class.” But when it comes to insurance, high net worth is more about value than wealth.

Consider homes as an example. A high value home is typically one that is valued at $750,000 or higher. With inflation and today’s property values, your home may fall in that range now, even if you didn’t pay that much to buy it. But if the size, location, and/or values of homes around you have increased – your home likely is worth more too.

In addition, do you have a more expensive vehicle? What about multiple vehicles? Do you have a boat, RV, ATV, or other additional vehicles? Do you have a gun collection, jewelry, or other personal property that might be worth more than your current policy’s limits. All these things add up, and they may need more coverage than is offered by “standard” home and auto policies.

Property isn’t the only place you face risk; you have personal liability as well. And the more you have, the more you may be sued for if someone feels you are responsible for some type of “damage” to them. Lawsuits are more common now, as are larger court judgments and settlements. Having more coverage for personal liability can help protect you and your assets.

So, do you need “special” coverage?

Maybe not “special” coverage, but you very well might need “different” coverage. Important things to check include:

  • Property limits on your policy – are they high enough for the value?
  • Coverage language like Replacement Cost versus Actual Cash Value – would you want to pay the difference if you had a claim?
  • Liability limits on your policy – lawsuits can be costly and adding more may not be as expensive as you’d think.

Things you should consider to better protect yourself:

  • Get the current property value of your home assessed and match your policy limits closer to that value
  • Take precautions to protect your property like home security systems, protection devices, home & roof inspections, and discussing safety with your family
  • Discuss valuable items like jewelry, firearms, and collections with your insurance agent to see if they need to scheduled on your policy
  • Consider a Personal Umbrella Policy (PUP) for additional protection

Make sure you understand your current policies, coverages, and limits. Review what you have and what you may need on a regular basis to make sure changes have been accounted for properly. It can make a huge difference in your protection whether you’re high net worth or not!

Want more tips to help better protect yourself and your family? Need a policy review? Contact Brandon from our team at brandon@ownbyinsurance.com or 865-453-1414 today.

Steps for Better Personal Risk Management

You could probably guess that companies need to take steps to reduce their risks, including safety programs, cybersecurity, and more. But should you be taking risk management steps for yourself? Do you have ways you can lower your own risks and potentially reduce the chances you have a loss or an insurance claim? The answer to both these questions is “yes” of course!

Driving Risks

Over 36,000 automobile accidents occur every day1 in the U.S. Many of these accidents are caused by distracted driving. One of the simplest steps you can take for better personal risk management is to avoid using your devices while driving. And while texting may be the most obvious, many people are using their phones for searches, looking up directions, or even watching videos! Avoid these while you aren’t parked in your vehicle whenever possible.

In addition, keeping your car in good working order is also a way to reduce your risk. Keep your tires properly inflated, have brakes and safety mechanisms checked, change windshield wiper blades as needed, and keep up regular maintenance to prevent mechanical issues that could cause an accident.

Cyber Risks

The average American accesses the internet for around seven hours of their day!2 Much of that may be for work, but many Americans also work from home. If you’re using your personal devices, take steps to protect your data:

  1. Protect your passwords and create stronger passwords whenever possible.
  2. Use multifactor authentication when it is an option for logins.
  3. Avoid using “open” or unsecured internet network connections.
  4. Be careful visiting websites and especially entering data on sites that do not have SSL encryption (https://).

Liability Risks

Lawsuits are on the rise in our country, and larger verdicts and judgments are more common. You can protect your own liability at home by taking steps that include:

  1. Fence in your yard, especially if you have a trampoline, pool, treehouse, etc.
  2. Avoid “overserving” alcohol to adults at your home – even friends and neighbors.
  3. Monitor and control your dog and/or other pets, even if they haven’t been known to bite.
  4. Talk with your family about being careful in their interactions with others, and the importance of safety.

These are just a few of the examples of ways you can be safer and also lower your risks. But accidents can still happen, and you need to have the right coverages in place in case they do. Contact Brandon Patterson from our team to better understand what those coverage options may be for you – brandon@ownbyinsurance.com or 865.453.1414.

1-per Progressive Insurance data

2-per Forbes data

What Do You Need to Cover Business Auto Use?

If your business regularly uses autos for business needs, you likely have risks. Whether it’s a fleet of vehicles or just one, and whether it is vehicles you own, lease, or your employees own – having the right coverages for business-use autos is critical.

Employer-Owned Vehicles

If your business owns autos for business use, you likely need a Commercial Auto policy. This will usually provide you coverage for liability damages, collision, or comprehensive auto property damage, bodily injury coverage, and property damage for other vehicles/property.

Additional coverages may include reimbursement for rental vehicles, under/uninsured motorist coverage, and/or medical payments coverage. Personal use of the vehicle may also be covered, but typically not by others (such as family members using the auto).

Non-Owned Vehicles

There are plenty of scenarios where your business may be using vehicles it doesn’t own. Maybe you’ve rented, leased, or borrowed a vehicle. Maybe your employees are using their own vehicles. For these situations, the risks are different, as you likely need coverage for property damage or bodily injury that your business is at fault for in an accident.

Hired and Non-Owned Auto coverage is often the solution here. The “hired” coverage provides protection for your business when you’ve rented, leased, or borrowed a vehicle. The “non-owned” coverage extends protection from and for your business over the employee’s personal auto policy. This likely adds to the limit that could be paid in the cases of property damage or bodily injury.

However, this is typically a “liability” only coverage, and doesn’t coverage damage to the non-owned property (the auto itself). That’s why it’s important to understand the underlying property coverages, such as the employee’s personal auto policy or the auto’s rental agreement coverage.

HNOA coverage might be available to add your business’s general liability policy, or it might be available to purchase separately as a “standalone” policy.

Additional Coverages

If you have greater risk potential for your business’s use of autos, you may want to consider adding a commercial umbrella. This type of policy may give you higher limits that could be paid on a claim for property damage, legal costs, medical bills, or even legal settlement payments. A variation of this may be excess liability that is specifically added for commercial auto coverage.

Whatever auto use your business has, it is important to understand the risks and coverage options available for you. This is also a scenario where understanding the exclusions of policies is extremely important.

Contact Brandon Patterson from our team at brandon@ownbyinsurance.com or 865.453.1414 to discuss your options for covering business autos.

Covering Your Trailer and the Objects You’re Hauling

As the weather warms up, more and more people are getting outdoors to enjoy nature. Maybe it’s boating on the water, taking an ATV off road, setting up camp in the woods, or getting projects done outside. And one thing all these might have in common is that trailers may be involved to move the items to their intended destinations. As you’re hauling, you may be wondering – am I covered? Let’s review some of the circumstances.

Covered by Your Auto Policy?

In most cases, the coverage of your trailer – while in use for hauling – will fall under the policy of the auto hauling it. But keep in mind that if you have liability only coverage for your auto, the same would apply for your trailer. In addition, the contents you are hauling on your trailer are not typically covered in these policies.

Boat Trailers

If you have a specific trailer for your boat or other watercraft, you may be able to purchase coverage under your boat insurance policy. However, unless you have designated the trailer as “dual purpose” on your policy, you are unlikely to be covered if you haul something on the trailer other than your watercraft.

Camper Trailers

Because of their different risks, you will likely need a separate policy to cover any kind of pop-up or camper trailer. In addition, the value of a campers “contents” alone would likely make it a wise decision to have specific coverage in place for them.

Other Coverages

Trailer-specific coverages, personal umbrella policies, and additions or endorsements to other policies may be available to cover your trailer and its contents.

In Tennessee, there is not a requirement for registration or insurance if you have a boat, farm, utility, or pop-up trailer. Other trailers do have registration laws in Tennessee, and since insurance for the auto hauling the trailer is required, there are still some approximate rules for coverage in the state no matter what you’re hauling with your trailer.

Contact Brandon Patterson from our team at brandon@ownbyinsurance.com or 865.453.1414 to discuss your trailer risks and options for coverage.

Risk Management and Your Team’s Role in Lowering Risk

Risk Management and Your Team’s Role in Lowering Risk

Workers’ compensation rates have been steadily dropping for the last decade in Tennessee and other states. And while factors like market competition and legal system improvements are factors, one of the biggest impacts has come from a reduction in claims frequency and claims severity. How has this been achieved? Safety and risk management programs. When better procedures are in place to protect employees, fewer accidents – or less damaging accidents – occur. So, could this be applied elsewhere to lower your businesses risks?

Preparing Your Team for Success

Onboarding, training, screening, and testing of employees and potential hires can help you lower risk. And this isn’t just for jobs with physical risks. Training your employees on cyber risks, onboarding them for customer interaction, screening them for past loss history, and intermittently testing them on what they’ve learned can all help with your risk management. Let’s review some examples of how this approach can be impactful.

Cyber Liability Prevention

Most businesses store customer data or personal info in some fashion. Whether it be loyalty info like names and birthdays or financial info like credit cards stored for recurring payments, this data is sensitive and must be protected. If you train and test your employees on avoiding cyber risks like phishing, hacking, and human error, you’ll be helping lower your cyber risk.

Third Party Liability Prevention

How does your team interact with customers? If there is a physical location that customers visit for goods, services, or transactions, is it well-maintained? Does your team know to clean up spills, report malfunctioning equipment, or notify management of unsafe conditions? Quickly acting on these concerns not only makes for a better customer experience, it may also reduce your risk.

Property Damage Prevention

If you work on or interact with customer property, having your employees properly trained is critical. Whether it be a $20,000 car or a $1,000,000 piece of equipment, the work your employees do shouldn’t put position you for a claim. And while accidents happen, the better the training, the less likely they are to occur.

Good risk management leads to better options for your insurance, especially as your business’s loss history continues to be good or improves from prior claims. Contact Brandon Patterson at 865.453.1414 or email brandon@ownbyinsurance.com to discuss how it could help your business.

Is Increasing Your Deductible a Good Idea?

Is Increasing Your Deductible a Good Idea?
We’d all love to save more money, and insurance isn’t something people typically enjoy spending money to purchase. There are ways to decrease the cost of your insurance premiums, and one that is often mentioned is increasing the deductible of the policies. But is this a good idea? That depends on your specific situation.

What is a Deductible?
As you probably know, your deductible is the amount you’ll be responsible for if you have a claim paid by the company that insures you. For example, on a home insurance policy, “cheaper” insurance often has higher deductibles, meaning a claim resulting in $10,000 of damages might cost you $5,000 out of pocket on that cheaper policy, while a “more expensive” policy may only result in only $1,000 out of pocket expense.

So, I Can Save That Money Now, Right?
If you purchase a less expensive policy with a higher deductible, you may indeed save money on the front end. But what about if you have a claim? Since none of us knows when a claim will occur, a plan to save on the front end until you have a claim may not work out for you. Let’s take a look at why with an example of premium and deductible differences on a home with $350,000 in dwelling coverage:

Average Annual Home Insurance Premium1                  Deductible

$1,595                                                                                                    $1,000

$1,522                                                                                                    $1,500

$1,441                                                                                                    $2,000

With these averages in mind, raising your deductible from $1,000 to $2,000 would save you $154 per year. But if you have a claim in the first twelve years of your policy term, you haven’t saved any money once you pay your deductible. And what if you have another claim soon after? Your deductible is typically paid at each claim occurrence, so that means another $2,000 out of your pocket.

Does it ever make sense to increase your deductible. Yes, there are instances where it would based on the premium differences and the individual’s financial situation. But that is something you’d want to review carefully with your insurance agent.

Our agents can discuss your options and help you find the coverage that’s best for you. Let us help you find the insurance policy terms that are right for you!

1 – Quadrant Information Services. Averages are for $350,000 worth of dwelling coverage.

What to Expect This Year in Insurance

Over the last 18 months, the insurance market has been “hardening” up. A hard market in insurance means that insurance companies are increasing their premiums and reducing the amount of risks they cover. This has been especially apparent on property (i.e., homes, buildings, rentals, etc.) and auto risks.

Catastrophic events are often the driver for this in the property marketplace. Wildfires, hurricanes, tornadoes, hail, and more can bring large losses and frequently in concentrated geographic areas. In the auto insurance marketplace, higher cost for parts, slower repair completion, more expensive replacements for electronics (e.g., hybrids, EV, microchips, etc.) have resulted in a similar increase in rates. Many companies have also reduced their offerings in the market as well.

When insurance companies pay out these larger claims, their profitability takes a hit. In fact, the property and casualty insurance industry as a whole experienced unprofitable years in 2022 and 2023, having a combined ratio of over 100% (under 100% traditionally means profit).1 While many expect a return to industry profitability sometime this year, the impacts are still taking place. Companies are charging more to insure property, whether it is a home, business building, or otherwise.

So, why should you care if insurance companies make a profit? Certainly, these are large corporations, some of which are worth billions. But they still support millions (almost 3 million in 20222) of people and provide safeguards for almost every individual and business in this country. The insurance industry is needed for our economy to function.

In 2024, it is likely that rates will continue to climb, but possibly at a slower rate. Then we anticipate that things may begin to “soften” as the year progresses. But you do have options as a consumer. Independent insurance agencies – like we are at Ownby Insurance Service – can shop your coverage for you with other insurance companies. Those that directly write insurance for national companies can’t offer that.

Our agents can discuss your options and help you find the coverage that’s best for you. Let us help you weather the hard market!

1 – Per https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/research/us-pc-insurance-market-report-profitability-to-remain-elusive-in-2023

2 – Per https://www.statista.com/statistics/194233/aggregate-number-of-insurance-employees-in-the-us/